📍 More near here · within 40.5 mi
Milk and Sugar Cafe
📍 49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
📱 Text me new haunts near Bay Shore, NY
New haunts & Halloween events near Bay Shore, NY — texted as they land on the map.
🎃 More haunts near this one · within 40.5 mi
NEW
The Witches Brew
👁️ 4 views
+ Tour
NEW
Coffee Labs Roasters
👁️ 4 views
+ Tour
NEW
The Hidden Oak Cafe
👁️ 3 views
+ TourAdds this haunt to your tour and opens the tour builder — drop in the neighbours above and share the whole route.
🔔 More haunts like this?
Be first to know when a new display lands near Bay Shore, NY — plus first access to the 🎄 Jolly Map this Christmas.
Map — loading as you scroll…
Get directions →
👻 More like this
Track 5 Coffee — Cranford
👁️ 10 views
+ Tour
NEW
Hungarian Pastry Shop
👁️ 7 views
+ Tour
NEW
Devoción — Farm-Fresh Coffee, Williamsburg
👁️ 7 views
+ Tour
NEW
Lloyd's Carrot Cake
👁️ 10 views
+ Tour
NEW
Beans and Leaves Coffee and Tea Café
👁️ 9 views
+ Tour
NEW
Carlo's Bakery — The Cake Boss Original
👁️ 8 views
+ Tour🗺️ Get your town's Halloween map
The best displays in Bay Shore, NY in your inbox — every new haunt as it lands, and the tour map when you're ready to go.
🧭 Keep exploring · nearest first
You've seen everything near here 🎃 — the map has the rest of the country.
